Book Review: Old Wounds

Reviewed By: Harriet Klausner

Old Wounds     Amazon US TPB Amazon Canada TPB
Nora Kelly
Class/Genre:   Mystery   Academic
Series: Gillian Adams # 4
Poisoned Pen, Nov 1999, $12.95, 300 pp.

After holding the chair of her school’s history department for a year, Professor Gillian Adams plans to take a sabbatical. She wants to spend time in London with her significant other Edward. However during a break, Gillian returns home to assist her mother who recently broke her hip. Gillian is shocked at how fragile her mother has become. Because of a weak heart, Gillian figures her mother has little time left. She changes her plan to spend time in Upstate New York with her mother. Gillian accepts a teaching job at nearby Stanton College.

However, the serene upper Hudson turns deadly when two students find the corpse of a peer, Nicole Bishop, in Dee’s Pond. It initially appears that a hunting accident occurred, but soon evidence surfaces that someone deliberately murdered Nicole. The police find a semi-nude picture of the victim inside the home of the town’s weirdo. Witnesses place the eccentric individual at the crime scene. In spite of the mounting proof, Gillian feels the prime suspect is innocent because she knows him quite well. However, as Gillian investigates, the police arrest someone else, who Gillian also thinks is innocent.

OLD WOUNDS is a slow moving, pondering academic mystery that challenges readers with each twist and turn. Action is not a by-word associated with this tale. The story line allows the delightful characters to show their true disposition and motives that dictate much of their behavior. Reminiscent of Joanne Dobson’s style of writing, Nora Kelly has provided fans of academic cozies with a pleasant novel.

Harriet Klausner

Reprinted with permission. Do Not repost without permission from the author, Harriet Klausner